Edited to perfection? 11/25/2009
Authors often assume that if they pay for an editor then their book should be 100% perfect. In reality, that's pretty much an unattainable dream. I have never read a book of more than 20,000 words that didn't have at least one thing I would change; whether it was as miniscule as a double space, or as major as a character's name suddenly changing midway through the book. When you think that editors are responsible for not only every word, but for every typeset character (and every fictional character's plausibility, dialogue and consistency in persona), every symbol and all of the spaces between them, as well as the correct arrangement of words, characters and spaces -- that's a lot to deal with right there. However, editors are also assessing line length and removing "tombstone" spaces; determining paragraph length; ensuring chapter length is consistent and that chapter ends create a "cliffhanger"; ensuring chapters link successfully to past and future events in the text; and removing non sequiturs, widows and orphans (phew!). In effect, editors are responsible for avoiding or fixing many thousands of potential errors (millions in some cases). They do all of this using a set of rather loose principles and guidelines: grammar, spelling, diction and punctuation. These are not always black and white and the flexibility of grammatical "rights and wrongs" differs between genres, with literary fiction usually being the most forgiving. The rules they live or die by also vary depending on house style and language of choice. So, basically, you'll rarely see a 100% error-free book, and what is 100% error-free to one editor might not be so to another. In fact, I'd challenge you to find me a book of more than 20,000 words that is 100% perfect by any editor's standards. Even if it is, the next year something might well happen (either a change in accepted grammatical style, new scientific research or a momentous historic event) that leads to your book needing a change at reprint. That's not to say that editors aren't valuable, but that, as in most things in life, perfection is a pipe dream. The best we can hope for is dedicated professionalism and a commitment to being as close to "perfect" as possible. Remember, writing is a craft... 04/11/2009
Recently a friend of mine suggested that I join an online freelance community in an attempt to break into the American writing market. Online networking sites, writing forums, and other creative communities can be excellent "workshops" for growing writing skills, and as I was no stranger to getting my inspiration, and some of my writing jobs, from off the web, I signed up to elance with little trepidation. However, my hopes of US domination were quickly dashed. Also dashed was any faith I might have had that writers were at last beginning to be respected as skilled professionals working in a trade that requires creativity, dedication and talent, rather than simply late-risers in unwashed T-shirts bashing off 500 random words before lunch. |
RSS Feed